Grand Theft Auto VI has finally arrived, but its launch is already generating some unexpected controversy. While critics have almost universally awarded Rockstar’s latest blockbuster perfect or near-perfect scores, players are sharing clips of characters falling through the map, bizarre physics glitches and questionable mission design that has prompted accusations of excessive hand-holding.
The game currently sits at 99/100 on Metacritic, putting it alongside The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time as one of the highest-rated games ever. However, there’s an uncomfortable paradox at the centre of the discussion: gamers want GTA 6 to be recognized as an extraordinary achievement, but when established publications give it the scores that reflect that enthusiasm, some immediately question their credibility.
GTA 6 Players Share Glitches and Question Mission Design
The first unusual clips began circulating as review and gameplay embargoes were lifted on November 18, with several streamers encountering problems before the game’s worldwide launch. One of the earliest examples involved streamer JasonTheWeen, who spotted a large boat apparently lodged between the supports of a bridge and a nearby wall. Rather than remaining stationary, the vessel began moving erratically as he approached. The clip was shared by yoxic on X, with Jason commenting: “I’m getting glitches and bugs already…13 years in the making.”
Other footage has been considerably stranger. One clip shared by Grand Theft Auto 6 Alerts shows a character falling through the ground during gameplay, while another video from streamer MichaelDoesLife shows Jason and a police officer awkwardly clipping through surrounding furniture during a confrontation.
Michael wasn’t particularly impressed, comparing the footage to Cyberpunk 2077’s infamous launch and writing: “It’s CYBERPUNK 2077 all over again what is this glitchy buggy mess. 13 YEARS for this. YIKES!”
There have also been reports of vehicles flying unexpectedly through the air, disappearing characters and strange collision detection. Individual examples are hardly evidence of a widespread technical crisis, but they’re attracting attention given the extraordinary expectations surrounding Rockstar’s latest release.
Performance is another point of contention, particularly on the standard PS5. Some players have reported frame-rate drops and stuttering during driving and combat, with clips circulating that supposedly show the game dropping to 15-20 FPS.
10/10 Reviews, Rockstar’s History With Critics and the Access Media Problem
The most interesting part of GTA 6’s launch might not be the technical issues themselves, but the reaction to its critical reception. IGN, GameSpot and Game Informer have all awarded the game 10/10, while Eurogamer, GamesRadar+ and Video Games Chronicle have handed out five-star ratings. The result is a Metacritic average of 99, despite some reviewers acknowledging shortcomings involving combat, mission design, performance and occasional bugs.
GameSpot has even addressed the apparent contradiction directly. Its reviewer Tamoor Hussain explained that a 10/10 doesn’t mean a game is perfect, but that it’s an essential experience that everyone should play. That’s also consistent with GameSpot’s published scoring policy, which explicitly states that a game can receive a 10 despite having issues.
Nevertheless, the reaction from gamers highlights a longstanding problem with how the public perceives gaming journalism. Whenever a major release receives overwhelmingly positive reviews, accusations of paid journalism, publisher relationships and reviewers acting as industry shills are rarely far behind.
This time, Rockstar’s own history has become part of the conversation, as Canadian technology journalist Patrick O’Rourke recently recalled his experience reviewing Grand Theft Auto V in 2013, claiming that Rockstar stopped providing him with review copies after he refused to award the game an overwhelmingly positive verdict.
In a post on his X account, O’Rourke wrote: “Rockstar blacklisted me in 2013 for not giving GTA V an overwhelmingly glowing review.”
He subsequently clarified that his review was actually positive, but that he found GTA V’s story less compelling than GTA IV’s. He also explained that he had been on Rockstar’s media and review-copy list while working for a national Canadian newspaper chain, but never heard from the publisher again after publishing his assessment.
Importantly, O’Rourke has also pushed back against accusations that Rockstar directly paid publications for positive GTA VI reviews. He doesn’t believe that happened, although he suggested that smaller outlets with less influence might be reluctant to publish particularly critical assessments if they fear losing future access to publishers.
Early review access is an established part of the industry, with publishers supplying advance copies to journalists ahead of launch. However, access can carry its own complications, particularly for smaller publications that rely on maintaining relationships to secure future review opportunities.
The disastrous console launch of Cyberpunk 2077 in 2020 demonstrated why these arrangements matter. CD Projekt Red initially provided review access primarily for PC, leaving console buyers without a proper indication of how badly their versions performed. The controversy eventually resulted in an apology and refunds.
Review disagreements aren’t necessarily evidence of misconduct, either. Pearl Abyss previously suggested that critics didn’t have enough time with Crimson Desert’s review build to appreciate its more distinctive qualities. Similarly, Hellraiser: Revival’s divided critical and player reception demonstrated how differently the same game can be perceived depending on who’s playing it.
It’s a weird paradox, as players want the game to be perceived as one of the greatest releases ever made, but many appear unwilling to trust the major publications telling them exactly that. Meanwhile, anyone offering a less enthusiastic opinion risks being dismissed as a contrarian or someone farming engagement.
GTA 6 Is Already Nominated for The Game Awards 2026
There’s another curious development that’s drawn ire and suspicion from gamers: Rockstar’s latest release secured eight nominations, including Game of the Year, Best Game Direction, Best Narrative, Best Art Direction and Best Action/Adventure Game, two days before its release.
This isn’t entirely unprecedented, as The Game Awards has an established system allowing publishers to provide voting outlets with advance copies and digital codes so they can meet nomination deadlines. Its eligibility cutoff is November 20, 2026, at 9pm PT, meaning GTA 6 qualifies despite arriving only one day before that deadline.
There’s also a sense of déjà vu here: GTA VI won The Game Awards’ Most Anticipated Game category in 2025 and in 2024. The nominations aren’t proof of review bias, but they do highlight how the industry’s awards calendar increasingly depends on advance access and pre-release critical assessments.
The Last Word
GTA 6 appears to have delivered an extraordinary open-world experience, but that doesn’t make it immune to criticism. The early glitches are worth documenting, the mission design is clearly a matter of taste, and the conversation surrounding its review scores raises legitimate questions about the relationship between publishers, journalists and audiences.
However, automatically dismissing every positive review as paid journalism is just as unhelpful as treating a 10/10 score as proof that a game has no meaningful flaws. Ultimately, GTA 6 should be judged on what it actually delivers, rather than on whether its reception fits a predetermined narrative of either perfection or failure.
Featured Image Credit
Image from Rockstar Games